THIS SITE HAS MOVED!

As of 9/18/15, this site has moved to www.jillygagnon.com

You can still read my blog posts here (you can also read them on the new site!), but visit www.jillygagnon.com for current information on everything else!

Monday, September 29, 2014

The Patina of Culture

Oh, that's SO Jungian.

Of course in CountryName social norms are just completely different.

Well the [Post-Modernists/Medieval ruling classes/Oneida Community Members/Basically any other movement-era-group-schoolofthought] were generally much likelier to [pick your blanket statement] than we are today.

I'm not the only one who bullshits this way, am I?



I think I'm a fairly informed person; I read (some of) my New York Times--even when it hasn't appeared in my facebook feed--and I've ticked the boxes next to several dozen "classic" works of literature. I'm not-fluent, but minimally dinner-party-conversant, in many major philosophies and/or zeitgeists. Perhaps most importantly, I care about knowing--or seeming to know--the things an educated person "ought" to. Sort of. Unless it means I have to actually read Kant.

GOD that stuff is dry-dactic.

But sometimes--by which I mean the vast majority of the time--I feel like I'm skating on a VERY thin surface of knowledge skimming over deep, DEEP waters of ignorance.

Some of this is things I maybe-once-knew but then 99% forgot (in this bin: all philosophical texts/movements, most important national and world history, and anything about any sport ever).

More of it is things I've never bothered to actually read/watch/culturally consume, and so have only ever managed to cobble together the flimsiest of ideas about.

"Briefly sounding kinda smart" is worth it, right?


It's the old "I'm a fraud" syndrome. Except it's definitely real--pretending I have any right to talk about most of the things I talk about is absolutely a lie. A pretentious lie at that.

I try to console myself with the idea that we're all doing this most of the time; there's just way too much STUFF out there for any one person to get to (at least without a generous patron and access to all social networks and/or Bravo TV blocked...at which point you will become way less culturally literate in Housewives trivia and whatever happens next that will TOTALLY BLOW YOUR MIND).

But then I get into a conversation about something I think I maybe sorta know, and the other person is just way more informed than me. I've read none of those books. I've heard none of those seminal albums. I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT THAT RELIGION IS.

Guys, PLEASE tell me I'm not alone about this.

If you do, I promise I won't throw in some totally half-baked "insight" next time we chat!

Though that will leave us with an extremely Doctor Who-centric conversation. But only the new seasons. I'm only "conversant" with the earlier incarnation...


2 comments:

  1. Part of it could be that you're trying to be a good listener and say something intelligent about what the other person is saying. Whereas many people just steer the conversation to something they find interesting and know something about. If you try to talk about something you are interested in, they shut off.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh god, I get caught up in that trap all the TIME! The smiling-nodding-pretending-offering-the-only-comment-you've-got-in-your-arsenal one, because you know if you steered things towards a place you COULD contribute s/he'd just be--and broadcast--bored.

    ReplyDelete